2022–2026 Term · Monday

February 12, 2024

City Council Meeting

6 motions · 6 procedural 1 Recorded

Motions

Confirmation of Agenda

#1 CARRIED

Council confirmed the agenda for the February 12, 2024 meeting, including all printed items and any new business that was added.

WITH RESPECT to the February 12, 2024 City Council, we recommend that the agenda as printed, including any additional information and new business, be confirmed.

Moved by Shelby Ch'ng , seconded by Dominic Pasqualino
#5 CARRIED

Council approved increases to golf course user fees for 2024, including adult season passes rising between 1.72% and 3.03%, and daily green fees increasing between 4.10% and 5.26% at city golf courses.

WITH RESPECT to Report 1-2024-Corporate Services -Office of the City Treasurer 2024 Proposed Operating and Capital Budget and the Memorandum from Manager – Parks and Open Spaces Cory Halvorsen, dated February 8, 2024, we recommend that the following user fees be approved as outlined:  Golf Season Pass – Adult (36 years to 59 years) Double (7 days/week) o increase – 3.03% – $1,504.43  Golf Season Pass – Double (Strathcona & Chapples 7 days/week) Intermediate Adult (23-25 years) o increase – 1.72% – $1,305.28  Daily Green Fees (Chapples & Strathcona 7 days/week) o 9 Hole  increase – 5.26% – $35.40 o 18 Hole  increase – 4.10% – $45.14

  • the above noted changes be included in the 2024 User Fee By-law.
Moved by Brian Hamilton , seconded by Michael Zussino
#6 LOST notable

Council rejected a proposal to delay Victoria Parkade repairs by one year, which would have moved $1,029,300 in funding from 2024 to 2025.

WITH RESPECT to Report 1-2024-Corporate Services - Office of the City Treasurer 2024 Proposed Operating and Capital Budget, we recommend that the Victoria Parkade Repairs capital budget for 2024 and associated financing from internal loans be decreased by $1,029,300:

  • the Victoria Parkade Repairs capital forecast for 2025 and associated financing from internal loans be increased by $1,029,300.
Moved by Rajni Agarwal , seconded by Dominic Pasqualino

Proposed Operating and Capital Budget, we recommend that the Victoria Parkade

#7 CARRIED Recorded vote: 13-0

Council approved increases to golf course user fees for 2024, ranging from 1.72% to 5.26% across various season passes and daily green fees at city golf courses.

WITH RESPECT to Report 1-2024-Corporate Services -Office of the City Treasurer 2024 Proposed Operating and Capital Budget and the Memorandum from Manager – Parks and Open Spaces Cory Halvorsen, dated February 8, 2024, we recommend that the following user fees be approved as outlined:  Golf Season Pass – Adult (36 years to 59 years) Double (7 days/week) o increase – 3.03% – $1,504.43  Golf Season Pass – Double (Strathcona & Chapples 7 days/week) Intermediate Adult (23-25 years) o increase – 1.72% – $1,305.28  Daily Green Fees (Chapples & Strathcona 7 days/week) o 9 Hole  increase – 5.26% – $35.40 o 18 Hole  increase – 4.10% – $45.14

  • the above noted changes be included in the 2024 User Fee By-law.
Moved by Brian Hamilton , seconded by Michael Zussino
Vote breakdown (13-0)
#8 CARRIED headline

Council approved Thunder Bay's 2024 budgets totaling $389.5 million in operating expenses and $79.9 million in capital projects, including funding for water, wastewater, solid waste, and waterfront services. The budget relies on tax levies, borrowed funds, reserve contributions, and grants to balance spending.

WITH RESPECT to Report 001-2024-Corporate Services-Office of the City Treasurer, we recommend that the proposed 2024 Operating and Capital budget for tax and rate supported operations be approved as outlined in this Report

  • the 2024 Tax Supported Operating Budget be approved at $389,511,900 as outlined in this Report
  • with respect to the Tax Supported Operating Budget, contributions to reserves and reserve funds from operations totalling up to $28,391,500 and transfers from reserves and reserve funds totalling up to $8,229,200 be approved as outlined in this Report
  • the Waterfront District Business Improvement Area levy of $113,000 be approved
  • the Victoria Avenue Business Improvement Area levy of $60,000 be approved
  • the 2024 Tax Supported Capital Budget be approved at $79,928,300 as outlined in this Report with financing as follows: Net Capital Financed by the Tax Levy $20,187,900 Debenture Debt (Annual) $ 7,648,600 Debenture Debt (Special – Victoriaville Phase II) $10,700,000 Internal Loans $ 1,260,600 Grants and Other Revenues $11,822,500 Reserves and Reserve Funds $28,308,700 AND THAT the 2024 Solid Waste (Landfill Operations) Operating Budget be approved at $3,345,100 gross expenditure and $363,800 net income, with a contribution to the Solid Waste – Landfill Reserve Fund to result in $0 net income
  • the 2024 Solid Waste (Landfill Operations) Capital Budget be approved at $1,819,400 gross, with the use of debenture debt ($1,320,000) and internal loans ($499,400) as the source of financing
  • the 2024 Wastewater Operating Budget be approved at $17,683,400 gross expenditure and $4,703,200 net income, with a contribution to the Wastewater Reserve Fund to result in $0 net income
  • the 2024 Wastewater Capital Budget be approved at $10,612,700 gross, with financing from the Wastewater Reserve Fund ($6,812,700), debenture debt ($3,000,000), and Disaster Mitigation & Adaptation grant funding ($800,000), AND THAT the 2024 Waterworks Operating Budget be approved at $22,343,300 gross expenditure and $8,269,000 net income, with a contribution to the Waterworks Reserve Fund to result in $0 net income
  • the 2024 Waterworks Capital Budget be approved at $12,346,000 gross, with financing from the Waterworks Reserve Fund ($7,746,000) and debenture debt ($4,600,000)
  • the 2024 Prince Arthur’s Landing – Boater Services Operating Budget be approved at $378,200 gross expenditure and $152,000 net income, with a contribution to the Boater Services Capital Reserve Fund to result in $0 net income
  • the 2024 Prince Arthur’s Landing – Boater Services Capital Budget be approved at $60,000 gross, with financing from the Boater Services Capital Reserve Fund ($60,000)
  • the User Fee Schedules A, B, D, and G be approved as outlined in Attachment A
  • reconciliation adjustments for the Budget presentation in accordance with Ontario Regulation 284/09 and Public Sector Accounting Board Standards be approved as outlined in this Report
  • any necessary By-laws be presented to Council for ratification including By- laws related to user fee changes.
Moved by Andrew Foulds , seconded by Michael Zussino

Ratifying Resolution

#10 CARRIED notable

Council approved two resolutions: one to move forward with recruiting a new City Manager, and another to establish terms of reference for a Housing Task Force under the Planning Services division.

THAT the following ratifying resolutions be introduced, read, dealt with individually: 1. Human Resources Matter – City Manager Recruitment; 2. Report 015-2024-Infrastructure, Development & Operations- Development Services-Planning Services - Terms of Reference - Housing Task Force.

Moved by Albert Aiello , seconded by Greg Johnsen

Procedural

#2 CARRIED Council confirmed the minutes from the January 22, 2024 meeting as an accurate record of what was discussed and decided.
Moved by Greg Johnsen , seconded by Rajni Agarwal
#3 CARRIED Council approved the official minutes from two Committee of the Whole meetings held in January 2024, including one closed session meeting.
Moved by Michael Zussino , seconded by Andrew Foulds
#4 Council approved the minutes from five budget planning meetings held in January and February 2024, and will consider changes to golf course user fees based on a manager's recommendation.
Moved by Andrew Foulds , seconded by Shelby Ch'ng
#9 CARRIED Council approved the official meeting minutes from five budget planning sessions held in January and February 2024.
Moved by Andrew Foulds , seconded by Shelby Ch'ng
#11 CARRIED Council approved four zoning and administrative by-laws: removing a holding symbol on John Street, making city-wide zoning amendments, updating municipal law enforcement appointments for parking enforcement, and exempting a condominium project at 115 Minot Avenue from planning approval requirements.
Moved by Kristen Oliver , seconded by Brian Hamilton
#12 CARRIED Council officially confirmed and sealed the proceedings from its February 12, 2024 meeting by formally adopting By-law 23/2024. This is standard housekeeping that validates the meeting's decisions.
Moved by Greg Johnsen , seconded by Albert Aiello